14 Best Rothy’s Dupes for the Most Comfortable Flats





Last Updated: August 10, 2022

We may earn a commission from links on our website, but this doesn't influence the opinions of our editors.

If you’re looking for the best Rothy’s dupes for a cheaper price, we’ve got you covered.

Not only are Rothy’s flats super comfortable, but they’re also unique. They are made from plastic water bottles, keeping ocean-bound marine plastics out of the waterways. (Check out our full Rothy’s review here for more info!)

This sustainable shoe brand has been worn by Megan Markle, driving sales of the trendy knit shoe up. But the downside is, they’re in the $150-$200 range. Are there any alternatives to this fashionable flat? Read our list of best Rothy’s dupes to find out.

And, if you’re just looking for some super comfy flats, check out our list of the most comfortable flats here.

1. Vivaia Pointed Toe Knitted Flats

#1 Best Rothy's Dupes Vivaia Pointed Toe Knitted Flats

This brand is almost a replica of the real deal. These knitted flats are machine washable, made from recycled materials, and look similar to Rothy’s. 

They aren’t a steal but still cheaper than Rothy’s markups.


2. Clarks Cloudsteppers

Clarks Cloudsteppers

These shoes are made by Clark’s, a brand known for their comfort and quality.

They come in many colors and prints and a similar knitted style to Rothy’s but for half the price. 


3. Allbirds Women’s Tree Breezers

Allbirds Women's Tree Breezers

Made with eucalyptus tree fibers, this shoe is silky smooth, machine washable, and sustainable. 

The shoes are breathable and come in many fun colors. They run about $100, still cheaper than Rothy’s. Plus, they’re included in our list of the most comfortable flats.


4. Lulu’s Emmy Camel Suede Pointed Loafers

Lulu’s Emmy Camel Suede Pointed Loafers

These sophisticated suede loafers are super similar to Rothy’s but for a fraction of the price. 

They’re pointed-toe and a chic camel color to fit any outfit in your closet. Plus, also they’re vegan!

RELATED: 27 Vegan Shoe Brands for Cruelty-Free Footwear


5. Vionic Women’s Lotus Dahlia Ballet Flat

Vionic Women’s Lotus Dahlia Ballet Flat

These flats by Vionic are about half the price of Rothy’s, but they have that same sophisticated style. 

They feature a point-toe, knit uppers, and a podiatrist-designed footbed for ultimate comfort


6. Amazon Essentials Women’s Loafer Flat

Amazon Essentials Women’s Loafer Flat

If you’re looking for a super inexpensive alternative with just as much style, these loafers from Amazon Essentials are our top pick. 

They offer a timeless design with faux suede lining for comfort. Plus, they come in 14 different colors!


7. Skechers Cleo Flats

Skechers Cleo Flats

These flats are a stretchy and comfy alternative for a very affordable option. They are machine washable and even have a memory foam insole.

However, they are not sustainably produced, if that’s eco-conscious shopping is important to you.


8. Ollio Ballet Comfort Flats

Ollio Ballet Comfort Flats

These shoes are probably the most inexpensive of Rothy’s dupes, including the pointed-toe design.

However, they aren’t sustainable or machine washable. But, they sure are comfy, though!


9. HEAWISH Women’s Ballet Flats for Women Pointed Toe Slip On

HEAWISH Women's Ballet Flats for Women Pointed Toe Slip On
22 Colors Available

These pointed-toe flats are made of comfortable mesh fabric and have a slip-on design, making them easy to put on and take off. Plus, they come in a variety of colors, so you’re sure to find a pair that suits your style.

Whether you’re heading to the office or running errands, these ballet flats are a great choice for comfortable, chic footwear at an affordable price.


10. Old Navy Textured-Knit Pointy-Toe Ballet Flats for Women

Old Navy Textured-Knit Pointy-Toe Ballet Flats for Women

These shoes are made with a textured knit fabric that gives them a unique look, and the pointed toe adds a touch of elegance, just like Rothy’s.

They’re also super versatile—you can wear them with jeans and a t-shirt for a casual look, or dress them up with a skirt and blouse for a more formal outfit.


11. Lattelier Pointy Toe Flat Shoes

Lattelier Pointy Toe Flat Shoes
Available in 4 colors

These stylish shoes feature a unique lattice detail that adds a touch of interest and flair. The pointed toe also gives them a modern edge. Whether you’re dressing up for work or heading out on a date, these flats are sure to turn heads.

Plus, they’re about half the price of Rothy’s flats.


12. Katliu Women’s Flats Knit Comfort Pointed Toe Ballet Flats Shoes Casual Slip On Shoes

These flats are made with a flexible knit fabric that conforms to your foot, and they have a classic slip-on design that makes them easy to put on and take off.

Plus, they’re available in a variety of colors, so you can find the perfect pair to match your wardrobe.


13. Frank Mully Women’s Pointed Toe Ballet Flats

Frank Mully Women's Pointed Toe Ballet Flats

Made with high-quality materials, these shoes are both comfortable and stylish. The pointed toe gives them a touch of sophistication, while the low heel makes them ideal for walking or standing for long periods of time.

Whether you’re pairing them with jeans and a tee for a casual look or dressing them up with a skirt and blouse for a more formal occasion, these flats are sure to become your new go-to shoes.


14. Lucky Brand ‘Emmie’ Flat

Lucky Brand 'Emmie' Flat

The coated cork fabric and leather upper of the Lucky Brand ‘Emmie’ flat makes it a unique and stylish choice for any outfit. The cork fabric is coated with a clear sealant, making it durable and easy to clean.

The leather upper is soft and supple, providing a comfortable fit. The flat also features a cushioned footbed and a textured rubber outsole to provide traction and prevent slipping. It is an excellent choice for any woman who wants a stylish and comfortable flat that will stand up to wear and tear.

In Conclusion

Several Rothy’s look-alike shoes go for a much lower price. There are even some sustainable, machine-washable options that go for a cheaper sale, but don’t compromise on style. 

We hope this list of the best Rothy’s dupes helped you find the right pair for you!

UP NEXT: VIVAIA Shoes Review: Sustainable Footwear at its Finest?

Leave a Comment